NFL Coach Fire and Hire Grades





I'll list the grades for the hiring and firing of each NFL coach and general manager, as well as most coordinators.

Follow me @walterfootball for updates.



Feb. 7 Updates

Packers hire DC Joe Barry: F Grade
There are plenty of promising positional coaches who deserved a chance to be a defensive coordinator in the NFL. The Packers ignored all of those options, choosing to hire proven failure Joe Barry instead.

I don't understand this decision. Barry has been a defensive coordinator twice throughout his career. His first stint was in Detroit, where he helped the Lions achieve an 0-16 record. He got a second chance with the Redskins, who ranked 28th in yardage allowed in both years Barry coached for them.

Barry is one of the worst defensive coordinators of this current generation. Why would the Packers give him a third chance? It would be like hiring Matt Millen to be the general manager, or Rich Kotite as a head coach. This move deserves an "F" grade.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.





Jan. 29 Updates

Texans hire DC Lovie Smith: B+ Grade
It's rare for the Texans to make a good decision, so putting a "B+" on the above line sent shockwaves through my system. I think I'm going to need some time to recover.

Lovie Smith was a failure as a head coach, particularly at Illinois, where he held a dismal 17-39 record. However, Smith has always been a sharp defensive coordinator, so he seems like a good hire. My one concern is that at 63, Smith may be exhausted and may not have any new ideas, but this hire should work for Houston.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.




Titans hire OC Todd Downing: C Grade
This was actually a promotion, as Todd Downing was the tight ends coach last year. The last time the Titans promoted a tight ends coach to offensive coordinator, it was Arthur Smith, so this move has obvious upside.

I can't say I'm very high on this "hire," however. Downing was the Raiders' offensive coordinator in 2017, so we have a glimpse into how he'll perform with the Titans. Downing's Raiders were 23rd in points and 17th in yardage despite the scoring unit being comprised of Derek Carr, Amari Cooper, Michael Crabtree, Marshawn Lynch and a talented offensive line. Downing will have plenty of talent to work with in Tennessee, but it's doubtful that he'll have the team as productive as it was under Smith.

The Titans also promoted Shane Bowen to defensive coordinator, but given that Mike Vrabel will continue to call the plays, I didn't think this move was worth grading.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 27 Updates

Texans hire HC David Culley: F Grade
The Texans have been the worst-run organization in the NFL in recent years, and that's saying something because there are several incompetent franchises. If it weren't for Deshaun Watson, Houston would have gone 0-16 in 2020. Given Watson's demands, that could happen this year if he's dealt.

It's not yet known what Watson thinks of David Culley, but he's not the most promising candidate to fill the last vacant head-coaching job. In his most recent coaching stints, Culley was Josh Allen's quarterbacks coach during Allen's pedestrian rookie year. Culley was promptly upgraded in the wake of Allen's struggles. He was then the passing-game coordinator for the Ravens, a team that struggled to move the ball aerially with Lamar Jackson.

It's not clear what the Texans see in Culley. Then again, all of their other moves in recent years have been puzzling, so this is just part of the trend.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Seahawks hire OC Shane Waldron: B Grade
The Seahawks have hired an upgrade over Brian Schottenheimer. Granted, almost anyone would have been an upgrade over him, but bringing in Shane Waldron was not a bad decision.

Waldron was the Rams' passing-game coordinator for the past three years. He did well with what he had in Jared Goff, though Sean McVay obviously had to do a lot with that. Still, Waldron learned from McVay, and he can also provide insight into a rival the Seahawks have problems beating, so there are definitely some positives to this hire.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 26 Updates

Lions hire OC Anthony Lynn: A Grade
Anthony Lynn's downfall as a head coach was his poor game and clock management. However, he was a good offensive-minded coach, so some team was going to make a great hire by bringing him in to run their offense. Detroit did just that, earning an "A" grade in the process.

Lynn was part of a coaching staff that accomplished tremendous things with Justin Herbert last year. Lynn also did a great job with Austin Ekeler. As a former running backs coach, Lynn figures to get the most out of D'Andre Swift, whom the Lions will build around moving forward without Matthew Stafford.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Eagles hire OC Shane Steichen: A Grade
The Eagles had some of the NFL's worst coaching last year. They've made dramatic changes for the better this offseason, and that includes hiring Shane Steichen to be their new offensive coordinator.

Steichen did a phenomenal job with Justin Herbert last season. Many considered Herbert to be raw and erratic upon his entrance into the NFL, yet Steichen transformed him into the offensive rookie of the year. Perhaps Steichen will be able to use similar magic with Carson Wentz and/or Jalen Hurts. Furthermore, Steichen and Nick Sirianni worked together in the Chargers' organization for several seasons, so the familiarity the two have with each other will allow for a smooth transition.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.



Chargers hire OC Joe Lombardi: D Grade
Really? Joe Lombardi? I wrote about a week ago that Brandon Staley needed to hire a brilliant offensive coordinator to help Justin Herbert's development, and all he could come up with was Joe Lombardi?

For those not familiar with this Lombardi, I wrote the following about him when the Lions fired him a few years ago: "Lombardi's offense was so predictable that the opposition was actually calling out the team's plays before the snap. Lombardi wasn't creative at all, and Detroit's offense has been stagnant as a result."

Perhaps Lombardi has learned some stuff since then. He was the Saints' quarterbacks coach for the past few years, after all, so he may have had something to do with Taysom Hill's development. Perhaps that'll help Herbert, but the play-calling is likely to be predictable.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.




Steelers hire OC Matt Canada: C Grade
This wasn't technically a hire, as Matt Canada was promoted from quarterbacks coach to offensive coordinator. Still, an e-mailer reminded me that I forgot this grade, so here we are.

The Steelers were correct to replace Randy Fichtner, but probably could have done better in their search of a new offensive coordinator. Canada might end up being a good coordinator, but he doesn't have much pro experience. It also bothers me that he has held jobs at seven different posts since 2011. He parted ways on "mutual terms" on multiple occasions, so that's not the greatest indicator.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 23 Updates

Panthers hire GM Scott Fitterer: A Grade
It's about time an NFL team hired someone from Seattle's front office. Both Scott Fitterer and Trent Kirchner, general manager John Schneider's top lieutenants, have been interviewing for jobs for several years. It was inevitable that at least one of them would be hired as a general manager, and the Panthers opted for the former.

The Seahawks have a tremendous front office, so it makes sense for the Panthers to pull the trigger on Fitterer. Seattle routinely finds great talent in the middle and late rounds of the draft, and Fitterer has been a big part of that. The same can be said of Kirchner, so that's someone else another front office could consider in the near future.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Rams hire DC Raheem Morris: A+ Grade
The Rams have been blessed with great defensive coaches during Sean McVay's tenure. McVay initially hired Wade Phillips and then replaced him with Brandon Staley last year. Staley moved on to be a head coach elsewhere, prompting McVay to make another great hire, bringing in Raheem Morris.

Atlanta's defense was a mess in the first half of the 2019 campaign. However, the Falcons named Morris defensive coordinator, and things quickly changed. Atlanta's defense improved tremendously despite the unit sorely lacking talent in several places. Morris also did a good job as the Falcons' interim head coach when Dan Quinn was fired, so the Rams did well to add him as Staley's replacement.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Falcons hire DC Dean Pees: A+ Grade
I didn't understand the Dave Ragone hire, but this is a tremendous move. Dean Pees was one of the top defensive coordinators in the NFL over the past 15 years before deciding to retire ahead of the 2020 campaign. He coordinated the 2012 Ravens to their Super Bowl, and Tennessee's defense fell apart without him after the 2019 season.

New Falcons head coach Arthur Smith was able to coax Pees out of retirement, as the two coached together in Tennessee. This is just a short-term hire because Pees is 71, but it's a tremendous one. It reminds me of Sean McVay getting Wade Phillips to be his defensive coordinator when he became coach of the Rams in 2017. Pees will instantly improve an always-underachieving Falcon defense over the next couple of years.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Falcons hire OC Dave Ragone: C- Grade
I almost didn't grade this hire because new head coach Arthur Smith will serve as his own play-caller with the Falcons. However, it was just too odd not to grade.

Who is Dave Ragone, you ask? Some may remember him as Louisville's quarterback long ago, but Ragone has most recently served as Chicago's passing-game coordinator. That's right. He was the passing-game coordinator of the Bears, a team that has had some of the most inept quarterbacking in the past several years.

I don't get it. This is like hiring Warren Sapp to be your accountant. I know that Smith and Ragone coached together a decade ago, but I don't see what Ragone can possibly contribute to the Falcons.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Jaguars hire OC Darrell Bevell: F Grade
Trevor Lawrence will be playing in the NFL on Hard Mode. The Jaguars have made all the wrong moves this offseason, hiring an exhausted head coach with no pro experience and a general manager who tried his best to ruin an NFL franchise. The Jaguars continued making terrible decisions, bringing in Darrell Bevell to be their offensive coordinator.

I've heard Bevell described as a "nice guy, but terrible coordinator." I don't know him personally, but I would agree with the latter sentiment. Bevell was able to get the least out of Russell Wilson during his 7-year tenure in Seattle. He then moved on to Detroit, where he wasted countless downs feeding the ball to the decrepit Adrian Peterson rather than D'Andre Swift. Bevell has been one of the worst offensive coordinators in the NFL over the past decade, so it's unclear why the Jaguars thought that hiring would be a good decision.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Bears hire DC Sean Desai: B+ Grade
Some people with low intelligence are calling this a great hire because of Sean Desai's non-football background, but that's nonsense, of course. I like the move though, so I'll give the Bears a B+ for promoting Desai to defensive coordinator.

There are several things wrong with the Bears, who had no business being in the playoffs this past season. However, the defense was not one of them. Chicago's stop unit has been stellar over the past several years, carrying Matt Nagy's inept offense throughout his tenure. The Bears' defense was especially great when Vic Fangio coached it, and Desai was apparently Fangio's right-hand man. Desai deserves a shot to coordinate Chicago's defense, so this appears to be a quality move.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 21 Updates

Jaguars hire GM Trent Baalke: F Grade
Wow. There are so many great general manager candidates available, and the Jaguars went with Trent Baalke? That's unreal.

Baalke ruined the 49ers in the middle portion of the last decade. When the 49ers fired him, I gave it an A++ grade. Here's what I wrote:

I don't think I've ever given an A++ grade for a coach hiring or firing, but this certainly warrants one. Trent Baalke has finally been axed as the 49ers' general manager, per a Jay Glazer report.

I can't believe it's finally happened. Baalke, along with Jed York, destroyed the 49ers' once-great franchise. Baalke got rid of Jim Harbaugh because he couldn't get along with a top-five NFL head coach. He followed that up by hiring "yes man" Jim Tomsula as a replacement, and he predictably proved to be a disaster. Baalke then brought in Chip Kelly, who was a proven failure as an NFL head coach. Kelly had already shown that he didn't understand simple NFL concepts, so hiring him was an insanely stupid decision.

Baalke's personnel moves were also very questionable. He managed to nail some draft picks, but he whiffed on plenty of selections, including A.J. Jenkins (first round, 2012), LaMichael James (second round, 2012), Tank Carradine (second round, 2013), and so on. He overpaid for some players - why are Vance McDonald and Garrett Celek getting a combined $50 million? - and made horrible moves in free agency, signing Zane Beadles, Reggie Bush (4 years, $16 million!) and Torrey Smith (5 years, $40 million!!!!).


This deserves an "F." The Jaguars still have a bright future with Trevor Lawrence, but Baalke will probably find a way to ruin things.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Falcons hire GM Terry Fontenot: A Grade
Terry Fontenot has never been a general manager in the NFL, but as I wrote with Brad Holmes signing, that's not necessarily a bad thing. Ozzie Newsome never held a job before becoming general manager of the Ravens in 2002, after all.

Fontenot doesn't have experience, but he certainly has promise. He's worked in the Saints' front office for the past 18 years. New Orleans has maintained one of the best personnel departments in the NFL this past decade. They routinely find stellar talents in the middle and late portions of the draft, and Fontenot was part of that decision-making.

The Falcons deserve a high grade for this move. As I wrote, there's lots of upside. It's also logical for the Falcons to go after an important member of a rival's organization, as Fontenot will undoubtedly give his new team some insight into what the Saints are doing.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Redskins hire GM Martin Mayhew: B Grade
Martin Mayhew served as Detroit's general manager for nearly a decade. He went 41-65 with the team, but was able to get them into the playoffs. That's basically like winning a Super Bowl with a better NFL franchise.

Mayhew was very hit-or-miss with his draft picks. There were the no-brainers like Matthew Stafford and Ndamukong Suh, but he also made some great choices like Kyle Van Noy, Darius Slay and Larry Warford. However, he was also responsible for drafting early-round busts like Jordan Dizon, Jahvid Best, Titus Young, Mikel Leshoure, Ameer Abdullah, Eric Ebron and Brandon Pettigrew. Luckily, the Redskins have running backs and tight ends, so Mayhew doesn't have to waste picks on those positions.

I think this is an OK hire. There were better candidates available, but the Redskins could have done much worse as well.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Eagles hire HC Nick Sirianni: A- Grade
Think Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie has some remorse about allowing Frank Reich to leave the team? Doug Pederson won the Super Bowl in 2017, but it's become increasingly evident that Reich was the true mastermind behind the operation. Carson Wentz has regressed without his former offensive coordinator, while the Colts have been able to benefit from his excellent coaching.

Lurie couldn't get Reich back, but he was able to obtain the next-best thing in Nick Sirianni, who has been Reich's offensive coordinator. Sirianni, who is only 39, is seen as the next young offensive guru. He's done an excellent job over the past decade as an offensive coordinator, quarterbacks coach and wide receivers coach for the Colts, Chargers and Chiefs. Sirianni has worked with Reich extensively, so perhaps he'll be able to bring the same great coaching back to the Eagles.

I like this hire quite a bit. Sirianni is obviously unproven as a head coach, but so were Sean McVay, Kyle Shanahan, Matt LaFleur, etc. Regardless, it's a good thing the Eagles didn't settle for a retread, given that they were rumored to be interested in Josh McDaniels.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 19 Updates

Lions hire HC Dan Campbell: B Grade
Dan Campbell, known otherwise as PC Head Coach, was the interim head coach of the Dolphins in 2015. He took over for the inept Joe Philbin and went 5-7 to close out the season despite coaching a team that didn't have much talent. Campbell's calling card was motivating his team. That, and supporting Strong Woman in her various athletic competitions.

I'm fine with this hire. I would have preferred a quarterback guru of sorts, but a motivational coach can be successful in the pros as long as he surrounds himself with a brilliant coaching staff. It remains to be seen what Campbell will do in that regard, though we know he tabbed Aaron Glenn to be his defensive coordinator. Glenn, serving with Campbell on the Saints' coaching staff as the defensive backs coach, is a smart guy who could have thrive in his new role. He had gotten the most out of most of his young defensive backs, so he'll at least improve the secondary.

I'll give the Lions a "B" grade for Campbell at the moment, but I could be more bullish on this hire once we know whom else he plans on adding to his staff. The Glenn hire is an A-, so Campbell is off to a good start.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 17 Updates

Chargers hire HC Brandon Staley: B Grade
I can't say I feel too strongly one way or the other with this hire at the moment. We'll learn more about this move soon, as Staley has a very important decision to make.

This, of course, involves Justin Herbert. Most expected the Chargers to hire an offensive head coach to help mentor Herbert, but Staley could just as easily find a brilliant offensive coordinator to do the same. Staley's tenure in San Angeles will hinge on that decision.

As for this hiring overall, Staley is young (38) and lacks experience, as he's been a coordinator just one year in the NFL. However, hiring young coaches like Staley has panned out in the past, and Staley did a masterful job with the Rams' defense as a replacement for Wade Phillips.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 15 Updates

Falcons hire HC Arthur Smith: B+ Grade
I've seen many complaints that the Falcons passed on Eric Bienemy, but this is just as good of a hire. It's not a slam dunk, by any means, but the Falcons did well in finding a replacement for Dan Quinn.

Smith did impressive work in Tennessee. He coordinated one of the top offenses in the NFL despite having to revive the careers of Ryan Tannehill and Corey Davis. What he accomplished with Tannehill was especially impressive; Tannehill was seen as a scrub quarterback prior to 2019, but the former Dolphin improved exponentially with the Titans.

Smith seems to get the best out of his players, so he should be able to do the same with either Matt Ryan or a quarterback chosen No. 4 overall.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Jets hire HC Robert Saleh: A+ Grade
There was some pessimism from Jets supporters once Robert Saleh was allowed to leave the building without a contract. Luckily for the Jets, they were able to agree to terms with Saleh before another team hired him.

Saleh was the top coaching candidate available. It was shocking that he didn't get an offer last offseason, but there was way too much interest for that not to happen this time. Then again, it could be argued that what Saleh did this year was more impressive than what he accomplished with his Super Bowl defense in 2019. Despite countless injuries to the defense - the 49ers had as many as eight starters missing at times - Saleh's 2020 unit finished fifth in DVOA!

In addition to being a great defensive coach, Saleh is beloved by his players, so his team will play hard for him. It's unclear how he'll fare in regard to clock and game management, but those are the only unknowns. With all that in mind, the Jets deserve an A+ for this hire.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 14 Updates

Lions hire GM Brad Holmes: A+ Grade
I've seen that some Detroit fans are upset about this signing because Brad Holmes has never been a general manager before. That doesn't make much sense to me because all first-time general managers were never general managers before their post. Ozzie Newsome, for example, was never a general manager before taking that job with the Ravens in 2002, and I'd say he worked out very well.

I'm strongly in favor of this hire. Brad Holmes had his work cut out for him as the college scouting director with the Rams because Los Angeles hasn't drafted in the first round since they selected Jared Goff first overall in the 2016 NFL Draft. The Goff pick wasn't Holmes' decision, but he was in charge of a team that identified many second- and third-day steals. Just look at some of picks in the past five years:

Cam Akers and Taylor Rapp (2nd round); Cooper Kupp, John Johnson and Joseph Noteboom (3rd round); John Franklin-Myers and Tyler Higbee (4th round); David Edwards and Micah Kiser (5th round); Jordan Fuller (6th round). All of these players are starters in the NFL right now. All of them! That's insane scouting.

Including Goff, the Rams have drafted 11 starters in the past five years despite having just one first-round pick in that span. The Lions did a great job of recognizing this, so I'm giving them an A+ for their hire.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Jaguars hire HC Urban Meyer: C Grade
I'm sure this will get lots of acclaim from the media and fans. Urban Meyer is a big name, after all, so he has to be considered a great hire by the Jaguars, who have endured Doug Marrone's poor coaching for years. However, I can't say I'm as bullish about the move.

I have two concerns about this hire. First, Meyer has never coached or played in the NFL. There's a long history of college-only coaches failing in the pros. There are, of course, exceptions to the rule, so it's not a guarantee that Meyer will fail for this reason. However, there's definitely a dubious track record going against him.

Second, Meyer tends to get burned out wherever he goes. How long is he going to last in Jacksonville? Will he still be enthusiastic to coach in two years, especially after enduring the rigorous NFL schedule? I have my doubts that Meyer will want to keep going after two or three seasons, which means Trevor Lawrence will have to learn a new offensive system by 2024.

Having said that, there's a chance this hiring will pan out. At the very least, it's a highly intriguing move.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 13 Updates

Broncos hire GM George Paton: A Grade
The Battle of the Bulge was nothing compared to what George Paton did in Minnesota. Working as Rick Spielman's right-hand man in Minnesota, Paton helped put together some terrific draft classes. By all accounts, Paton is an excellent talent evaluator, so he deserved a chance to be in charge of personnel decisions for an NFL organization.

The Broncos made a strong hire here, and I think they deserve an "A" grade for it. It's nice that John Elway didn't go for a failed retread, opting instead to go for upside.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 12 Updates

Seahawks fire OC Brian Schottenheimer: A+ Grade
So much for the Seahawks retaining Brian Schottenheimer. News broke that the Seahawks planned on keeping their horrible offensive coordinator despite Seattle's severe offensive struggles down the stretch. Apparently, Seattle had a change of heart.

This was obviously the right move. Seattle's offensive shift in the second half of the season made no sense. Utilizing a run-first offense crushed the team's scoring ability in the final weeks, including the playoffs. Schottenheimer called a terrible game against the Rams, so it would have been a big mistake to retain him. Seattle should get an A+ for making the correct decision.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Raiders hire DC Gus Bradley: A- Grade
It's interesting that two former Seahawk defensive coordinators were hired at the same position in a span of 24 hours. While Dan Quinn was hired by the Cowboys, Gus Bradley will be joining the Raiders.

I like this hire more for the Raiders because Bradley has been more successful as a defensive coordinator for a longer time and with multiple teams. Bradley also coordinated the Chargers the past four years, with his defenses finishing 15th, ninth, sixth and 10th in yardage allowed in that span.

Another positive to the Bradley hire is that he's familiar with the AFC West. His defense did a great job against Patrick Mahomes in Week 2 last year, so it made sense for the Raiders to bring him in as their next defensive coordinator.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Cowboys hire DC Dan Quinn: B+ Grade
Prior to coaching the Falcons, Dan Quinn was the Seahawks' defensive coordinator. He did an excellent job with Seattle, which earned him the Atlanta job. Things didn't pan out with the Falcons, so he'll return to his former duties with the Cowboys.

The Seahawks got worse defensively when Quinn left the team, though he had some amazing talent to work with in Seattle. It could be pointed out that the Falcons' defense was routinely abysmal under Quinn, and it actually improved upon his firing, but it's not like Atlanta had many good players on the defensive side of the ball. Their ineptitude was more on the front office than anything else.

Given that Quinn has performed well as just a defensive coordinator, he deserves another shot. This is not an amazing hire, but Quinn figures to be an upgrade over what the Cowboys had last year.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 11 Updates

Eagles fire HC Doug Pederson: A- Grade
Philadelphia waited for a Super Bowl for decades. Doug Pederson finally led the team to a championship to conclude the 2017 campaign. If you were to tell an Eagles fan at the time that the team would fire Pederson three years later, they would have called you crazy.

And yet, it's the correct move. I don't think it's a no-brainer like the Doug Marrone and Adam Gase dismissals, but it's become quite apparent that Pederson wasn't as responsible for the Super Bowl victory as many initially believed. Pederson assembled a terrific coaching staff that helped the team prevail. When those assistant coaches departed, the Eagles progressively got worse. Owner Jeffrey Lurie reportedly wanted to see Pederson assemble a great staff once again, but was apparently "underwhelmed" by Pederson's ideas. Hours later, Pederson was canned.

It's also worth noting that Pederson lost his locker room, which is another reason this firing makes sense. Pederson benched Jalen Hurts in Week 17 to improve his draft positioning. While this was a good move for the team in the long run, the players didn't respect this decision. In fact, some players had to be held back from confronting Pederson on the sideline. I thought at the time this could ultimately cost Pederson his job, and that's exactly what happened.

Either way, Pederson was doing a poor job of preparing the Eagles each week. They constantly underachieved following the 2017 campaign, so changes needed to be made.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 4 Updates

Chargers fire HC Anthony Lynn: D Grade
I gave the Jets and Jaguars A+ grades for firing Adam Gase and Doug Marrone, respectively. I'm not as high on this decision by the Chargers, however.

Anthony Lynn was the laughing stock of the NFL for a couple of weeks because of some games in which he displayed some abysmal clock management at the end of halves. However, Lynn improved in this regard late in the year, and the Chargers suddenly started winning close games as a result. They actually went on a tear to close out 2020, winning their final four games to finish 7-9. The players fought hard for Lynn to keep his job, which says a lot because the Jets and Jaguars didn't play very hard all the time at the end of the season.

I'm also not a fan of removing Justin Herbert's offensive coach so soon into his career. Herbert set all sorts of rookie records, thanks in part to Lynn's guidance. Herbert will now have to play in a new system, which could stunt his development.

The more I think about it, the more I hate this move. I initially penciled in a "C" grade for this firing, but I've dropped it to a "D." Considering how well the Chargers finished in 2020, and how amazingly Herbert played as a rookie, the Chargers should have given Lynn one more season.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Jaguars fire HC Doug Marrone: A+ Grade
Doug Marrone never should have had the job in the first place. He sabotaged the previous regime in order to obtain a position of power. He eventually lucked into some success in 2017, but we quickly learned that this was a fluke. Marrone should have been fired last year, but it's better late than never to can a horrendous coach.

Marrone's biggest problem is that like Bill O'Brien, he butted heads with too many players in the locker room. The players mostly despised Marrone and wouldn't fight for him. This actually turned out to be a blessing in disguise because the Jaguars' horrible effort late in the year allowed them to obtain the No. 1 overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft.

With Trevor Lawrence joining the team in April, the Jaguars need to move on with a much better head coach. There are many great candidates available, but almost anyone would be an upgrade over Marrone.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 3 Updates

Jets fire HC Adam Gase: A+ Grade
Adam Gase is good at only two things: 1) getting his best players to play at their worst, and. 2) winning meaningless games at the end of the year to ruin draft positioning. Unfortunately for Gase, those two elements do not lead to success in the NFL.

Good riddance, I say. Gase was an anemic coach in every way possible, and the Jets would've been the laughing stock of professional sports had they retained him for one more year.



Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 21 Updates

Panthers fire GM Marty Hurney: A Grade
When I heard of the Marty Hurney firing Monday morning, I was a bit surprised. Didn't he draft two studs in D.J. Moore and Brian Burns? And isn't his second-round selection of Donte Jackson doing well? Yes, but those are the only positive things he did ahead of the 2020 NFL Draft class, which can't be judged quite yet. Take a look:



Yuck! Outside of Moore, Burns and Jackson, there were no other hits. Marquis Haynes has been OK, but that's about it. Will Grier and Rashaan Gaulden were utter wastes in the third frame.

I'm fine with the Panthers thinking that they need to go in a different direction. Hurney's been around long enough for us to know that there are better options.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 14 Updates

Raiders fire DC Paul Guenther: A- Grade
The Raiders' offense has been explosive at times this season, but the defense has been the reason for the Raiders' recent collapse. Las Vegas surrendered 44 points to the Colts this past week and couldn't stop the winless Jets the previous Sunday. Las Vegas was 28th in points allowed prior to the Indianapolis loss.

It's clear that the Raiders needed a change, and firing Guenther could just save their season. I'm not sure that firing a coordinator on a very short week - the Raiders play on Thursday - is the best time to do it, but I can't criticize this decision otherwise.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 7 Updates

Jets fire DC Gregg Williams: F Grade
Gregg Williams is an awful defensive coordinator. He was most responsible for the Jets' loss to the Raiders, leaving the deep part of the field wide open for Derek Carr to throw the decisive touchdown to Henry Ruggs. Williams has done stupid things like this throughout his career. He was also the key component of Bountygate, so it's puzzling as to why he was the Jets' defensive coordinator in the first place.

So, why the "F" grade for this firing? Because letting Williams go increases the Jets' chances of winning this year! The Jets almost had the most harmful victory in franchise history versus the Raiders. Had they gotten the win, they would've lost out on Trevor Lawrence because the Jaguars have the tie-breaker with the Jets for the No. 1 pick if the two teams finish with the same record. Williams' presence gives the Jets the best chance to lose, which is what the team needs to accomplish at this time.

Had the Jets fired Williams after finishing 0-16, I would have given this an A+ grade. However, the Jets are making the right move at the wrong time, so they should be graded harshly for that.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Nov. 30 Updates

Jaguars fire GM David Caldwell: A+ Grade
I was convinced that David Caldwell had compromising photos of Jacksonville's owner because it made no sense that he would hold his job for so long. Charlie Campbell did a great job of breaking down Caldwell's follies in this video (please hit like and subscribe!):



To summarize, Caldwell drafted...

Luke Joeckel over Lane Johnson
Blake Bortles over Khalil Mack
Dante Fowler over Brandon Scherff/Amari Cooper
Leonard Fournette over Patrick Mahomes/Deshaun Watson
Taven Bryan over Lamar Jackson

Caldwell also paid big bucks to Nick Foles and presided over the Doug Marrone fiasco where Marrone sabotaged the previous coaching regime to seize control within the organization.

The Jaguars needed to fire Caldwell years ago, but I guess it's better late than never. The organization needs to bring in a sharp decision-maker to help build around Justin Fields.

Here are some NFL general manager candidates for the Jaguars replace Caldwell.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Nov. 28 Updates

Lions fire HC Matt Patricia, GM Bob Quinn: A Grade
Matt Patricia was the last person on Earth who realized that he should be utilizing D'Andre Swift over Adrian Peterson. With everyone calling for Swift to dominate the workload, Patricia and his staff constantly had their geriatric running back dive for 2-yard gains rather than lean on their talented, young back. This resulted in losses earlier in the year, which the Lions couldn't come back from when Matthew Stafford and Kenny Golladay suffered injuries later in the year.

Patricia did not do anything well as Detroit's head coach. He failed to prepare great game plans, and despite being known as a defensive genius by some, he failed to upgrade Detroit's stop unit. In fact, the Lions have gotten worse defensively under his watch.

As for Bob Quinn, let's check out his first- and second-round picks from 2016 to 2019:

Taylor Decker, OT
A'Shawn Robinson, DT
Jarrad Davis, LB
Jalen Tabor, CB
Frank Ragnow, C
Kerryon Johnson, RB
T.J. Hockenson, TE
Jahlani Tavai, LB

Quinn hit with some mid-round gems like Kenny Golladay, Jamal Agnew, and Joe Dahl, but this list is ugly. The offensive linemen and Tavai have performed well, but the rest of the first- and second-rounders were busts. T.J. Hockenson is technically not a bust, but spending a top-10 pick on a tight end was a very dubious decision.

Meanwhile, here were Quinn's big-money signings:

Lions sign OT Halapoulivaati Vaitai (5 years, $50 million)
Lions sign CB Desmond Trufant (2 years, $21 million)
Lions sign LB Jamie Collins (3 years, $30 million)
Lions sign TE Jesse James (4 years, $25 million)
Lions sign DE Trey Flowers (5 years, $82.5 million)
Lions sign CB Justin Coleman (4 years, $36 million)

Wow, what great moves! OK, maybe not. Quinn obviously did a poor job of assembling talent in Detroit, so his firing, much like Patricia's, deserves an "A" grade.

Here are some NFL head coach candidates for the Lions to replace Patricia.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Oct. 11 Updates

Seahawks extend HC Pete Carroll: A Grade
Pete Carroll has done an amazing job with the Seahawks. Despite his age (69), he has been effective in adapting to new trends. He solved the Seahawks' major issues with playing in early East Coast games, which used to be automatic losses for them, and he has morphed his offense to cater toward allowing Russell Wilson to throw more often.

Carroll will be 74 when this new contract reportedly expires, so this is likely the final extension he'll sign. If so, the Seahawks will be in position to win Super Bowls each year until then. Thus, this must be given an "A" grade.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Oct. 11 Updates

Falcons fire HC Dan Quinn and GM Thomas Dimitroff: A/B Grade
Everyone makes mistakes. The problem is repeating mistakes, so the Falcons are doing a great job of avoiding repeated blunders by firing Dan Quinn.

The Falcons should have fired Quinn last year, but the coach saved his job by winning some meaningless games late in the year. This ended up being harmful in the long run, as Atlanta missed out on landing Chase Young, Derrick Brown or Jeff Okudah in the 2020 NFL Draft, as they had to settle for A.J. Terrell with the 16th pick instead. There was some optimism for the Falcons heading into 2020, but they continued to drop winnable games, including two where they led by double digits in the second half. This, of course, was a repeat of what transpired in Super Bowl LI when they blew a 28-3 lead to the Patriots. Quinn at least did a good job of getting the team there, but I think we now know that Kyle Shanahan was most responsible for it.

A Quinn firing allows the Falcons to tank, perhaps giving them a shot at landing Justin Fields or even Trevor Lawrence (I have them taking the former in my 2021 NFL Mock Draft.) They can move on with a new regime, which is what they need to do. Thus, I'm giving the Quinn firing an "A" grade.

I'm not as bullish on the Thomas Dimitroff firing, but I can get behind it. Dimitroff has done a decent job of acquiring talent over the years, and he built some teams that have reached the NFC Championship or further. However, Dimitroff made some crucial mistakes in recent years, including his failure to fire Quinn last year. I don't have a problem with Atlanta pursuing a new general manager. Here are some potential general managers for Atlanta:



Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Oct. 5 Updates

Texans fire HC/GM Bill O'Brien: A++++++++ Grade
Wow, I'm shocked. I thought the Texans would never fire Bill O'Brien. Owner Cal McNair went out of his way to defend O'Brien multiple times on Twitter. It was so odd that I was going to write an Emmitt on the Brink entry about McNair taking O'Brien as his lover. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

Though I'm utterly surprised, this is the right move. O'Brien has been an abysmal personnel decision-maker for the Texans, and he's also been highly disliked by his players. Deshaun Watson had also seen regression under O'Brien. He had to go.

This firing doesn't just deserve an A+ grade. It deserves an A++++++++ grade. Eight pluses...

One plus for trading Jadeveon Clowney for nothing.

One plus for trading DeAndre Hopkins for nothing.

One plus for trading two first-round picks for Laremy Tunsil.

One plus for trading a third-round pick for Duke Johnson and then not using him properly.

One plus for trading a second-round pick for Brandin Cooks.

One plus for ousting general manager Rick Smith.

One plus for firing everyone in what was formerly the top scouting department in the NFL.

One plus for blowing a 24-0 lead to the Chiefs in the divisional round of the playoffs.

I've never given an A++++++++ grade before, but then again, we've never seen anyone as incompetent as O'Brien hold so much power in the NFL. Sure, we've had Matt Millen and Rich Kotite, and the like, but O'Brien was both the worst coach and the worst general manager for years.

The good thing is, it's done. The nightmare is over. O'Brien is finally gone. This is a move that should've been done years ago, but better late than never.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Sept. 1 Updates

Chiefs extend HC Andy Reid, GM Brett Veach (6 years): A+ Grade
Andy Reid and Brett Veach were both extended to 6-year deals Monday night. When I saw this, I thought I'd grade these moves when financial figures attached to them were available. However, Facebook friend Blake H. reminded me that the money is irrelevant, so I can grade these moves now.

I love both of these moves by the Chiefs. Veach has proven to be an outstanding general manager, while Reid is arguably the second-best coach in the NFL, trailing only Bill Belichick. Reid is 62, so there was some question as to how much longer he would remain in Kansas City. Assuming Reid stays on throughout the duration of his contract, Patrick Mahomes will be 30 by the time the Chiefs potentially have a new head coach. Over the next six years, Reid can help Mahomes transition from the best quarterback in the NFL to someone who could eventually be known as the greatest quarterback in league history, so keeping Reid for six years is a no-brainer.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 28 Updates

Texans name Bill O'Brien general manager: F- Grade
If the Texans knew what they were doing, they would've fired Bill O'Brien years ago. His team's epic collapse against the Chiefs was further proof of his incompetence as a head coach. O'Brien has gotten lucky to win the division several times during his tenure in Houston, but only because Deshaun Watson carried him in an AFC South that has been mostly lackluster in recent years. Houston stands no chance of making a deep playoff run as long as O'Brien is calling the shots. He's that horrible.

As bad as O'Brien is as a head coach, he's far worse as a personnel decision-maker. He has no feel for talent - he didn't even want to draft Watson - and he trades away draft picks as if they were nothing. He has no concept of leverage, which is why he dealt Jadeveon Clowney for a ham sandwich. He can't work with talented personnel evaluators. He wants all the power, and he doesn't get along with anyone. He's probably the least-qualified person in the NFL to be general manager of the Texans.

This is the easiest F- grade of all time. Hiring your cat to do your taxes would be a better decision than the Texans giving O'Brien more power.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 27 Updates

Browns hire GM Andrew Berry: F Grade
The Browns had their sights set on Vikings general manager George Paton. They interviewed him twice, but Paton removed his name from consideration after the second meeting. Paton undoubtedly realized that the Browns just wanted a "yes man" to be the general manager, so he correctly decided that he should wait for a real job.

Cleveland moved on from Paton and found its "yes man." That would be Andrew Berry, who was involved in the Browns' former 1-31 tenure. I don't know why anyone would hire someone who was partly responsible for a 1-31 record to be the general manager, but these are the Browns we're talking about, so they were bound to do something stupid.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 24 Updates

Jaguars hire OC Jay Gruden: C Grade
Jay Gruden didn't have a very successful tenure as the Redskins' head coach, but he did a good job as Cincinnati's offensive coordinator before then. I'm sure this hire will be seen as a positive by many because of that.

I'm personally not too sure about that reasoning. It seemed as though Gruden lost his passion for football late in his Washington tenure. I think he needed some time off to regain his fire. I know this isn't anything that's concrete, and I can't say anything here that can prove it, but I think my hunch is correct, so I don't want to grade this very favorably.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 17 Updates

Giants hire OC Jason Garrett: D- Grade
When I heard that the Giants hired Jason Garrett, I assumed it was for the open male cheerleader position. Garrett claps so enthusiastically that I figured he would be a great fit for the job.

However, this was not the case. The Giants apparently thought it was a good idea to make him the offensive coordinator. This is confusing because Garrett once called the plays in Dallas, but was so bad at it that he had to relinquish his play-calling duties. Given that, why do the Giants think that Garrett would be a quality option as their offensive coordinator? It's not like Garrett has any sort of new ideas. He hasn't had any time off to brainstorm any new innovations, so I'm not exactly sure what he's bringing to the table, outside of some knowledge he has of the rival Cowboys.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 15 Updates

Broncos hire OC Pat Shurmur: B+ Grade
The Broncos hired Pat Shurmur to be their replacement for Rich Scangarello as their offensive coordinator. Kenny described Shurmur as plain Cheerios in our DFS podcast:



And I agree. He certainly is not Fruity Pebbles, or even Honey Nut Cheerios, for that matter. Shurmur is a solid offensive coordinator. He's going to be an upgrade over what the Broncos had last year. There may have been more upside in other hires - Chad O'Shea, for example - but there's certainly a high floor with Shurmur. If Drew Lock fails, it won't be because his offensive coordinator let him down.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 14 Updates

Panthers hire OC Joe Brady: C Grade
This grade isn't fully based on how I believe Joe Brady could fare in the NFL, but rather the situation. Brady did a tremendous job coaching up LSU's offense this past season. I can definitely understand why teams would be interested in hiring him as their offensive coordinator, like the Panthers did.

However, I don't like the fit in Carolina. New head coach Matt Rhule barely has any NFL head-coaching experience. He needed to bring in coaches who have spent lots of time in the NFL. This is something Sean McVay did when he became the youngest head coach in the pros. He brought in Wade Phillips and Greg Olson, both of whom were vital to his early success. Rhule needed to do something similar, but Brady, like Rhule has barely spent any time in the NFL.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 12 Updates

Browns hire HC Kevin Stefanski: D Grade
The Browns reportedly were eyeing Robert Saleh and Kevin "Run, Run, Pass" Stefanski as two of their final head-coaching candidates. The two squared off in the divisional round of the playoffs, and Saleh coached circles around Stefanski. You'd think that after that performance, Cleveland would favor Saleh to be their head coach. Of course, this is why the Browns are the Browns.

Stefanski did a rather unimpressive job in Minnesota. His run-run-pass play-calling was predictable, and he struggled to get the most out of all the talented players on his offense. Only Dalvin Cook lived up to expectations in 2019. Adam Thielen and Stefon Diggs, conversely, were frequently frustrated with their roles.

I'm not sure what kind of "leader of men" Stefanski is, but he obviously pales in comparison to Saleh in that regard. Saleh was the better candidate, by far, and yet the Browns made the decision to hire a coach, presumably, because they didn't have one and wanted one now. This is the sort of decision-making that Browns fans have become accustom to under the horrible regime of owner Jimmy Haslam. While Haslam is a smart, albeit allegedly crooked businessman, he's pretty dumb when it comes to owning an NFL franchise, and this is yet another stupid decision on his part.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 9 Updates

Eagles fire OC Mike Groh: A+ Grade
The Eagles also fired receivers coach Carson Walch, but let's focus on Mike Groh, who was a failure of an offensive coordinator. He was given two years after Frank Reich moved on to Indianapolis, and he did a poor job as Reich's replacement. Carson Wentz regressed under Groh's watch, and it's not like the play-calling was innovative and unpredictable. The Eagles can do much better than Groh as their offensive coordinator, so it would've been a failure had they not fired him.

By the way, some of the blue checkmarks on Twitter seemed peeved that Doug Pederson lied to them. Pederson told the media Wednesday that he planned on retaining Groh, so he's being accused of lying. First of all, Pederson is not required to tell the truth to journalists. Second, it's possible that Pederson could have changed his mind after thinking about the situation and discussing it with other people within the organization. Thus, I really don't care that Pederson did something different 24 hours after saying the complete opposite to reporters.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 7 Updates

Redskins hire OC Scott Turner: D Grade
My "D" grade for this hire doesn't have much to do with Scott Turner. Ron Rivera has familiarity with Turner, as the two worked together in Carolina last year. Turner did a nice job with the receivers, so he deserved a chance to be a full-time offensive coordinator.

My issue regarding this hiring is allowing offensive coordinator Kevin O'Connell to walk. I don't overly prefer O'Connell to Turner, as both are young offensive-minded guys with upside, but I don't think that putting Dwayne Haskins into a new system is a good idea. One of the primary reasons young quarterbacks fail is because they're constantly learning new systems. Haskins showed some major improvement late in the year under O'Connell's tutelage, so why begin anew? And what if Turner sucks? The Redskins will have to fire him and bring in a new coordinator, and then Haskins will be starting from scratch a third time. This could ruin his career.

I don't like this decision-making from the Redskins. Again, this is nothing against Turner, but I think separating Haskins from O'Connell is a bad idea.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Giants hire HC Joe Judge: B+ Grade
Who is Joe Judge? Interesting question! Judge was the Patriots' special teams coordinator since 2015, and he also took over wide receiver coaching duties this past season. He never played in the pros, but he's been with New England since 2012, and he coached under Nick Saban at Alabama prior to that.

Judge is a surprising hire, but it's not like special teams coordinators haven't panned out in the past. Just look at John Harbaugh; he's one of the best coaches in the NFL even though he was the Eagles' special teams coordinator before taking the Baltimore job. Judge has a lengthy history of learning from both Bill Belichick and Saban, which is not insignificant because we've recently seen Belichick's former assistants thrive in the NFL.

I like the Giants taking a chance on an unknown with a great background over hiring a proven failure like Jason Garrett. This deserves a favorable grade just for that reason alone. I like this hire.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Panthers hire HC Matt Rhule: C- Grade
Matt Rhule was a tremendous college coach. He took over two dead programs - Temple and Baylor - and brought them to prominence. He nearly led Baylor to a Big XII championship, falling just short of defeating Oklahoma. This was very impressive, so I can understand why NFL teams were highly interested in him.

However, I'm not sure how this translates to the pros. Reviving a pair of bottom-barrel college football teams, which barely had any NFL-caliber talent, has nothing to do with motivating professional athletes. In fact, Rhule has never coached a professional athlete in his life, save for 2012 when he was the Giants' assistant offensive line coach. That's his only NFL experience.

There's an extensive history of college-only coaches failing in the NFL, so I don't see why Rhule would be any different in Carolina. What Rhule is proposing might seem impressive, as he's planning on instituting a sports science and recovery program. That sounds great, and those who believe in analytics will love how different it is from Ron Rivera's successful regime, but getting the players to buy in is not a given. Chip Kelly tried something similar in Philadelphia, and it failed miserably. I'm not sure Rhule can connect with NFL players using science and analytics, despite what the blue checkmarks on Twitter may think.

I don't think it's a given that Rhule will fail in the pros, but there's some major history going against him. Panthers owner Bobby Axelrod even gave Rhule a 7-year contract, which is ridiculous enough for me to grade this in the C-/D+ range.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 6 Updates

Rams fire DC Wade Phillips: F Grade
This is incredibly stupid. The Rams improved defensively this past season compared to where they were during their Super Bowl run. They were ninth in defensive DVOA even though their stop unit had to be on the field more often as a result of the offense stalling out because of Jared Goff's regression.

The Rams wanted a scapegoat because they missed the playoffs, so it ended up being Phillips. This was a bizarre conclusion for Sean McVay and the front office to make, given that Phillips barely had anything to do with the Rams' disappointing 2019 campaign. The Rams will be worse defensively without Phillips, as there is no viable replacement for the legendary defensive coordinator.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Cowboys hire Mike McCarthy: LOL Grade
I'm grading this as an "LOL" because I literally laughed out loud so hard that I nearly threw out my back when I first saw this news.

If there's been a coach who has been nearly as bad as Jason Garrett in the previous decade, it was Mike McCarthy. In fact, I saw someone describe McCarthy as a "fatter Jason Garrett," and I thought it was brilliantly accurate.

People will point to the fact that McCarthy won the Super Bowl, but that was Aaron Rodgers winning in spite of McCarthy. If the Packers had a coach better than McCarthy, they would've claimed multiple Lombardi Trophies with Rodgers. As everyone learned this year, McCarthy held back the Packers from reaching their full potential. He utilized archaic and predictable schemes, showed no feel for the game, and constantly clashed with his future Hall of Fame quarterback. In fact, Rodgers even lost on purpose to Arizona in 2018 because he despised McCarthy so much.

McCarthy did such a poor job in Green Bay that I would've shocked if he earned another head-coaching gig in the NFL prior to seeing this news. Yet, here we are. The Cowboys, for some strange reason, have decided to hire McCarthy in what is an utterly embarrassing move. Almost anyone would've been a major upgrade over Garrett, but McCarthy was one of the few exceptions.

It took the Cowboys six years too long to fire Garrett, yet they're stuck with the same trash coaching them. This is the easiest "F" grade I've ever posted. Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to fetch my heating pad.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 5 Updates

Cowboys fire HC Jason Garrett: A+ Grade
I had the urge to grade this as a "C" or something of that nature, only because it took Jerry Jones five years too long to make this decision. It was clear that Jason Garrett wasn't a good head coach by 2014. Everyone knew this except Garrett and anyone clueless enough to believe he'd be a good head coach of their team at the present moment.

Garrett always prepared his teams poorly, struggled to make adjustments and was frequently out-coached by the opposition. He had no feel for the game, and his teams always underachieved. I don't understand what took Jones so long, but he finally made the correct decision.

As for Garrett's next stop? The only thing Garrett does well is clap enthusiastically, so any NFL team in need of a male cheerleader should pursue Garrett for that position.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Jan. 1 Updates

Redskins hire DC Jack Del Rio: A Grade
The Redskins made another outstanding hire. Jack Del Rio has proven to be a very mediocre head coach, but he's been an excellent defensive coordinator throughout his career. He should be able to vastly improve Washington's beleaguered defense.

Del Rio has been out of the league the past two years after he was fired as Oakland's head coach, which could be a good thing. The time off to surf the waves may have energized Del Rio, who could have some new ideas to bring to his latest post. He's also another authoritative voice to turn things around for a team that sorely lacked discipline.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 31 Updates

Browns fire GM John Dorsey: C- Grade
The Browns are being the Browns once again, I see. It's amazing how this organization just doesn't seem to understand how to function properly. Firing good personnel men is not a good recipe for success. Owner Jimmy Haslam is a moron when it comes to football matters, but perhaps he'll learn this one day.

John Dorsey made some mistakes with the Browns, most notably failing to bolster the offensive line after trading Kevin Zeitler away for an aging edge rusher. I don't understand that trade at all, and hiring Freddie Kitchens was a major blunder, but Dorsey did so many more positive things. He built a good roster that most head coaches could've turned into a playoff contender. I think the Browns could've gotten there had Dorsey hired a much better coach after firing Kitchens, but this franchise will have to begin anew once again.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Jaguars retain HC Doug Marrone: F Grade
I may have to send another invoice. This time, to ESPN's Dianne Russini, who published some fake news about the Jaguars planning to fire Doug Marrone following Week 17. This led to a five-unit bet on the Colts in what was a disastrous Week 17.

In Russini's defense, it made all the sense in the world for the Jaguars to fire Marrone. The players completely quit on him in the second half of the year, so why would they retain him? Marrone has no positive attributes as a coach, and his own players don't even like him. This might be the dumbest decision any NFL team makes this offseason, so this is an easy "F" grade.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Dolphins hire OC Chan Gailey: D Grade
I can't say I understand why the Dolphins felt the need to downgrade from Chad O'Shea to Chan Gailey. The 68-year-old had been out of the NFL for three years after bombing with the Jets. Perhaps he picked up some new tricks during his hiatus, but I doubt it.

The one positive about this signing is that Gailey has worked with Ryan Fitzpatrick before, so it's nice that Fitzpatrick will know Gailey's system. However, Fitzpatrick didn't do particularly well with Gailey in 2016 - he threw for 17 interceptions and only 12 touchdowns - and was much better with O'Shea, so none of this makes any sense to me.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Redskins hire HC Ron Rivera: A Grade
New Panthers owner Bobby Axelrod made a big mistake by firing Ron Rivera this past season, so the Redskins should consider themselves fortunate that they obtained one of the best coaching options available. This is a terrific hire, worthy of an "A" grade.

Rivera built a winner in Carolina, and he can do the same in Washington. He's capable of constructing a great defense, and the players will work very hard for him. Most of all, he brings respectability to the sidelines, which might sound trivial for most teams, but the Redskins need it after all of the Trent Williams drama that occurred this past season.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 30 Updates

Dolphins fire OC Chad O'Shea: F Grade
There must be something going on behind the scenes because this firing doesn't make much sense otherwise. Chad O'Shea did a fantastic job as Miami's offensive coordinator this season. He was masterful in finally getting the most out of DeVante Parker, while Ryan Fitzpatrick never regressed under O'Shea's watch, like he did under other coaches.

I have to grade this an "F," at least until we receive some news about this. O'Shea should be highly sought after, as he'll be a terrific hire for any team in need of an offensive coordinator.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Giants retain GM Dave Gettleman: B+ Grade
Like Bruce Allen, Dave Gettleman is widely hated by the media. Gettleman's politics aren't in question, but rather his aversion to analytics. Gettleman has some archaic stances, but contrary to progressive groupthink opinion, that's not necessarily a bad thing. Gettleman built a good team in Carolina and has made some positive decisions with New York, though with some glaring mistakes mixed in.

Gettleman was widely criticized for selecting Daniel Jones sixth overall, but Jones showed high upside during his rookie campaign. He seems like he could become a great quarterback in the future, provided he gets some good coaching. Gettleman also found Darius Slayton in the fifth round and made some terrific free agent signings and trades. For instance, he obtained Kevin Zeitler for an aging pass rusher, and he signed Markus Golden (10 sacks in 2019) to a very cheap deal. Conversely, Gettleman has blown some selections, particularly the cornerbacks he has chosen in the early rounds.

I don't understand why the Giants would consider firing Gettleman. They can at least wait and see if Jones ends up being as good as some people think he can be. No one expected the Giants to do well in 2019 because they would have a rookie signal-caller going through growing pains, so committing a panic move by firing Gettleman probably would've been a mistake.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 30 Updates

Giants fire HC Pat Shurmur: A Grade
Pat Shurmur, in three head-coaching stints, which includes an interim gig with the Eagles, is 17-45 in his career. I could be wrong, but winning 27.4 percent of games is not going to cut it in the NFL.

While Shurmur is a quality offensive coordinator, he has shown no signs that he can be a successful head coach in the NFL. He constantly made mistakes with the Giants, while other coaches easily out-schemed him on a weekly basis. Shurmur was not one to galvanize the troops either like a Mike Tomlin or a Ron Rivera, so I'm not sure what he brought to the table as a head coach.

I don't see how this decision could be criticized in any way. Shurmur was doing a poor job in every facet, and I didn't trust him to fully develop Daniel Jones, so the Giants are better off finding someone better to fill his job.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Redskins fire team president Bruce Allen: D Grade
This is a move the media has greatly applauded this morning. It seems as though the consensus in the press is that firing Bruce Allen was a tremendous decision by the Redskins. The media, as usual, is wrong.

Let's think back to what happened a couple of years ago. Almost all sports writers and everyone on ESPN and NFL Network constantly criticized for the Redskins not extending Kirk Cousins. Washington was constantly chided for not paying Cousins what he wanted, but despite the heavy criticism, Allen was steadfast in his belief that Cousins was not a franchise quarterback. Rather than dive deep into cap purgatory, Allen opted to let Cousins go, choosing instead to acquire Alex Smith. Cousins ended up as a huge failure for the Vikings, while the Redskins - most forget this - were 6-2 last year and seemed poised to win the division easily before Smith suffered a gruesome, potentially career-ending injury.

The Redskins had to begin anew following Smith's injury, so they drafted Dwayne Haskins, who played well in his final couple of starts this season. Allen was also able to surround Haskins with some young, promising talents like Derrius Guice, Terry McLaurin, Steven Sims Jr., and Kelvin Harmon, none of whom were selected in the first round of any NFL Draft. Defensively, Allen found steals like Quinton Dunbar, Shaun Dion Hamilton and Matt Ioannidis, all of whom performed well in 2019. Dunbar was especially tremendous.

Allen built a promising, young group that could contend for the playoffs soon, and also had plenty of cap space to spend this offseason. Yet, the circle-jerking media, which has not accepted responsibility for being dead wrong about the Cousins stance, is thrilled about this decision. They have an irrational hatred for Allen, perhaps because of his politics, so despite what they say, this is not a move that will benefit the Redskins over the long haul.

Perhaps it was just time for a change, and Allen made some mistakes just like any other general manager. However, there's no reason to think that the Redskins will improve in the wake of his firing, despite what sports reporters have to say. If most of the media is telling you something, the opposite is usually true, and that certainly is the case in this instance.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 29 Updates

Browns fire HC Freddie Kitchens: A+ Grade
The Browns had no choice but to fire Freddie Kitchens, so this can't be graded as anything less than an A+. Kitchens is simply not suited to be a coach in the NFL. Whether it's making abysmal play-calls, having no feel for the game, being responsible for Baker Mayfield's regression, or fighting publicly with his players, Kitchens did everything wrong and nothing right in his one and only season as Cleveland's head coach.

Cleveland absolutely had to fire Kitchens to prevent another dumpster fire next year. More importantly, keeping Kitchens around could've further ruined Mayfield's career to the point where he'd be broken beyond repair. The Browns need to hire a sharp, offensive-minded coach to tutor Mayfield so that the young quarterback can pick up where he left off in his rookie campaign.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 28 Updates

Falcons retain HC Dan Quinn: A- Grade
The Falcons lost out on Chase Young, Jeff Okudah and perhaps even Derrick Brown because they didn't fire Dan Quinn in the middle of the season. Thus, it wouldn't make any sense for them to let him go at this stage.

Quinn made some great adjustments during the bye, allowing the Falcons to go 5-2 following their week off. They laid just one egg, which was a blowout loss to the Buccaneers, but that was four days prior to a Thanksgiving battle against the Saints. Otherwise, Atlanta has played very hard and well for Quinn in the second half of the season, so it seems like the right decision to retain him.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Dec. 18 Updates

Jaguars fire VP of Football Operations Tom Coughlin: A Grade
Tom Coughlin was a Hall of Fame-caliber coach, but that didn't translate to the front office. The Jaguars regressed every year under Coughlin, as he wasted draft picks and spent way too much money on Nick Foles. He was also forced into trading one of the best cornerbacks in the NFL. Coughlin made some good decisions, but Jacksonville has gotten worse under his leadership.

If this weren't bad enough, Coughlin violated CBA rules by fining players for non-football reason, prompting the NFLPA to advise free agents not to sign with Jacksonville. Coughlin had to go, so the Jaguars made the correct decision to fire him.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.





Dec. 3 Updates

Panthers fire HC Ron Rivera: C- Grade
It was a great run for Commander Adama, but his tenure in Carolina is over, as the Panthers fired Ron Rivera Tuesday afternoon. So say we all.

Losing to the Redskins at home is grounds for a firing, but I don't think this is a particularly good move. I don't understand how it's Rivera's fault that he didn't have a healthy Cam Newton all year. I thought it was rather impressive that the Panthers were 5-3 at one point despite ranking in the mid-to-low 20s in DVOA. Rivera clearly got his team to play above its talent level, so why would he be fired?

I don't absolutely hate this move because I think the Panthers can do better with a more innovative coach, but Rivera was good at his job and didn't deserve to be axed. I think we're going to quickly discover that new Panthers owner Bobby Axelr-, I mean David Tepper is far worse at his position than Jerry Richardson was. This might just be a first example of Tepper's terrible meddling.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Oct. 29 Updates

Chargers fire OC Ken Whisenhunt: A+ Grade
It's about time. I don't know why Ken Whisenhunt has been employed by the Chargers for so long. Maybe it's because he looks like Bill Cowher? I have no idea, but the Chargers finally made the right move by canning him.

The Chargers need to enter the 21st century. They've spent too much time trying to establish the run with the out-of-shape Melvin Gordon, while their offense has moved at a very glacial pace. The camel that broke the straw's back, as a former NFL player once said, was Whisenhunt's decision to completely ignore Austin Ekeler in last week's game plan. The Chargers won that contest, but a better offensive game plan centered around Ekeler would have resulted in a San Angeles blowout victory rather than a close call that was decided by a missed field goal.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Oct. 17 Updates

Redskins fire HC Jay Gruden: A+ Grade
This is a no-brainer A+. I used to think highly of Jay Gruden, but it's become apparent that he hasn't been taking his job seriously. It's almost like he got burned out from being a head coach, both literally and figuratively.

Gruden's nonsensical decision to start Colt McCoy over the team's first-round rookie quarterback was the final camel that broke the straw's back, as a Hall of Fame running back once said. It was clear Gruden wanted to get fired and receive money in the process, but the Redskins apparently one-upped him by releasing the video of him smoking weed. Whoops!

My only criticism was that this didn't occur sooner. The Redskins reportedly had the video of Gruden a year ago, so why didn't they fire him during the offseason, when it was apparent that he lost his team late last year and was against the Dwayne Haskins pick?

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


Aug. 18 Updates

Buccaneers extend GM Jason Licht (3 years): F Grade
Umm... what? Are we in an alternate universe where Jason Licht didn't constantly screw up? I don't understand this move. I suppose, if you're the Buccaneers, any time you have a chance to extend your horrible general manager, you have to do it.

Licht has committed blunder after blunder while running the Buccaneers. His first-overall quarterback is on the verge of officially being declared a bust. He traded up for a kicker in the second round of the NFL Draft. He spent too much money on Eagles cast-offs who haven't done anything. He gave lots of money to his terrible left tackle, Donovan Smith. He passed up on Derwin James in favor of two-down player Vita Vea when there were tons of talented defensive tackles to be had the following year. He wasted a second-round pick on Ronald Jones. Licht has made some good selections as well, but even a blind squirrel finds a nut sometimes.

I don't understand the need to do this. Was Licht going anywhere if the Buccaneers didn't extend him? Couldn't they wait to see if his new batch of players panned out? Licht has done nothing to warrant any sort of extension, so this has to be graded as an "F."

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


June 7 Updates

Jets hire GM Joe Douglas: A Grade
Charlie Campbell tweeted this back on May 15:

Scouts around the league are saying it's a done deal that Joe Douglas is the Jets general manager. Director of college scouting Jon Carr might get a sham interview to satisfy the Rooney Rule but they think the Jets and Douglas have an agreement.

It only took 23 days, but the Jets finally hired Joe Douglas. Perhaps they did this in response to the Texans firing Brian Gaine, as they may have feared they'd lose Douglas to Houston.

It's unclear how Douglas will fare as general manager for the Jets, given that he's never held that post before. However, he was a top scout for quite some time and was the vice president of personnel for a Philadelphia team that has been excellent as far as personnel moves are concerned, so this seems like it could end up being a great hire.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Texans fire GM Brian Gaine: A Grade
A year ago, Bill O'Brien nonsensically fired many talented people in Houston's personnel department because he wanted "yes men." O'Brien was able to pick his own replacement, so he had the Texans hire Brian Gaine. It turns out that Gaine didn't even last an entire year.

O'Brien really embarrassed himself with this move. The Texans made some blunders in the offseason, most notably not having a "Plan B" for when Andre Dillard was not on the board at No. 23 overall. Houston humiliated itself by reaching for Tytus Howard, who was considered by some to be a third-round prospect. Gaine, as a result, was fired.

On the surface, it looks bad to get rid of a general manager after one year, but it was clear that Gaine was doing a poor job. If the Texans want to make better personnel decisions, they'll hire someone O'Brien doesn't recommend this time. This next general manager may want to find a better head coach.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.


May 15 Updates

Jets fire GM Mike Maccagnan: B Grade
Mike Maccagnan's tenure as the general manager of the Jets produced mixed results. He was guilty of some horrible picks on the second day of the NFL Draft - Christian Hackenberg, Jordan Jenkins and ArDarius Stewart - and there were some poor free-agent signings. These were the three worst moves:

Jets re-sign WR Quincy Enunwa (4 years, $36 million; $20 million guaranteed)
Jets sign C Spencer Long (4 years, $28 million)
Jets re-sign G Ben Ijalana (2 years, $11 million)

However, Maccagnan had more positive transactions than negative ones. He hit some gems on the third day of the NFL Draft, as Chris Herndon and Elijah McGuire both outplayed their draft status, while sixth-round corner Derrick Jones showed some potential late last year. Maccagnan also was able to secure Sam Darnold by trading up without surrendering too many resources, and he brought in some nice free-agent signings as well, including Le'Veon Bell, Avery Williamson and Teddy Bridgewater at cheap prices. Bridgewater didn't stick around in New York because of Darnold, but Maccagnan was able to flip him for a third-round pick, which was an excellent move.

I'd normally grade the Jets poorly for firing Maccagnan, who didn't deserve to lose his job. However, there were reports of major friction between Maccagnan and new head coach Adam Gase. The Jets would've been hurt by a toxic situation like that, so I think it's best for the two parties to move on. Gase was just hired, so it would've made no sense to get rid of him. Thus, it's natural that Maccagnan had to be the one to be fired.

Comment on the other coach firings below.

Follow me @walterfootball for more hiring/signing grades and updates.

Click here for previous head coach hiring and firing grades.


LOADING COMMENTS...





2022 NFL Mock Draft - May 4


NFL Power Rankings - April 4


NFL Picks - Feb. 8


Fantasy Football Rankings - Jan. 11




 





 

© 1999-2021 Walter Cherepinsky : all rights reserved
Privacy Policy
2 5 9
Google

WalterFootball.com is part of the NESN digital network.