The Las Vegas Raiders held the first pick of the 2026 NFL Draft, and on April 23 in Pittsburgh, Roger Goodell read out their choice, Fernando Mendoza. Mendoza wasn't in the crowd. The Indiana quarterback and Heisman winner celebrated at home in Miami, the Associated Press reported, and Pro Football Talk wrote that the Raiders took him "as expected."
A fan watching that night had numbers on nearly every name that followed. There was an athletic score for each prospect who ran the combine drills, and there were analysts' boards that had been online for months. Those numbers changed how fans argue about a pick. They didn't change who heard it first.
That was a small circle inside each team building. Before every draft, the league sends a reminder about the integrity of the selection process to owners, general managers, head coaches, personnel directors and IT directors. How far a fan's numbers can reach depends on which side of that wall an outcome sits.
A Lions fan with a math habit gave the draft a shared athletic scale
Kent Lee Platte started on the problem in 2012. He's a lifelong Detroit Lions fan with a taste for math, and he noticed that the words his friends used for prospects, explosive and strong among them, often fell apart when he checked a player against others at the same position, NBC Sports Boston reported in 2023.
His answer, the Relative Athletic Score, turns combine measurements such as height, weight and drill times into one number on a scale of 0 to 10. Each player is set against everyone measured at his position, with records going back to 1987. A 9.9 puts a prospect near the high end of that pool.
Within three days of the 2026 draft, Platte had ranked all 32 classes by their average score, Pro Football Network reported. Tampa Bay finished first at 9.68 and Chicago second at 9.47. Then came the footnote. Tampa Bay's average covered four players, because three of its picks didn't test enough to get a score, first-round defensive end Rueben Bain Jr. among them.
So the class that led the ranking left its own first-round pick out of the math, and the 9.68 said nothing about him.
Game data opened up in a similar way. An open-source package called nflfastR, public since 2020, pulls the league's play-by-play from its own website and attaches an expected-points value to each snap. A fan with a laptop can rank every passer by expected points added per play.
Both tools moved fan arguments from raw totals to rates, per play or per position. They share a limit, too. They measure what happened in public, on a field or against a stopwatch, and the next outcome here was settled in a meeting room.
A pick is known inside the building a day early, and in 2026 it had a price
In 2016 the San Diego Chargers wanted edge rusher Joey Bosa at No. 3, and most of the prominent media mock drafts sent someone else there. Tom Telesco, then the team's general manager, told ESPN's Robert Klemko in April that 20 to 30 people would have known the likely pick 24 hours before the draft, from ownership meetings, scouting sessions and internal whispering.
No public number could have found that. Bosa's testing and his college tape were open to anyone. The Chargers' preference lived in one building, and a draft pick is decided before it's announced, which makes it a different kind of outcome from a game.
That gap had a price this spring. By draft week, Kalshi's users had put about $2 million into contracts on who would go second overall, Klemko reported. The Jets took edge rusher David Bailey at No. 2.
A contract on a draft pick is a sports event contract, which GamingToday defines on its prediction market sports page as a single yes-or-no proposition, worth $1 at settlement when the outcome occurs and $0 when it doesn't. Further down, the same page asks whether trading them is legal in the US and reports that more than a dozen states have sued, investigated or otherwise challenged sports event contracts since early 2025, with results going both ways.
The NFL's own rules already limit what its people may do on these platforms. In August 2025 the league's chief compliance officer said its gambling policy covers them, so players can't trade on NFL events and league employees can't use them at all, ESPN's David Purdum reported. The pre-draft reminder rests on that policy too. A league spokesperson told Klemko it asks staff to protect the selection process "through adherence with the NFL Gambling Policy and Draft-related security measures."
The league has taken its objection to court as well. On Oct. 8 it filed a brief supporting New Jersey's request for Supreme Court review of Kalshi's case, Purdum reported. Kalshi's federal registration as an exchange is with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, and New Jersey and other states argue that their gambling laws reach the company's sports contracts anyway.
Kalshi's court protection now depends on the circuit. In April 2026 a 2-1 Third Circuit panel upheld the preliminary injunction that blocks New Jersey's enforcement against it. On Aug. 28 the Ninth Circuit agreed that its Nevada injunction should be dissolved, and the Sixth Circuit's Sept. 25 decision left it with none in Ohio or Tennessee. Kalshi owes the justices a response by Nov. 9, and they aren't expected to act on the petition before December.
A draft price deserves less trust than it looks like it does. Anyone holding the wrong side of a contract loses the full amount paid, and when 20 or 30 people already know the answer, the buyers without that knowledge are the ones most likely to be wrong. Kalshi says it screens and bars athletes, coaches, trainers and others from trading on a sport they're connected to, Klemko reported. The groups Klemko listed are roles, so the screen may miss a scout's friend who heard the pick secondhand.
Eight regular-season throws can't grade the No. 1 pick
Back to Mendoza. The Raiders kept Kirk Cousins as their starter, and by late October the rookie's only regular-season snaps had come on the final possession of a 45-17 Week 5 loss at New England. He completed 6 of 8 passes for 48 yards and was blitzed on 22.2% of his dropbacks, Ryan McFadden reported for ESPN on Oct. 30.
Coach Klint Kubiak said that week that the plan to develop Mendoza "has not changed. That's been the plan all along." The team had lost four straight at the time, and a Week 8 win over the Jets brought it back to 4-4.
Ten years ago, a fan might have called that line a promising debut or a forgettable one. The data habit adds a third answer, too few plays to say, and this early it's usually the right one. Eight passes can't carry a rate stat. One sack or one deep completion could swing his expected points per play a long way in either direction.
The blitz figure probably says more about how that defense chose to treat a rookie than about the rookie himself. Mendoza's college record was a different matter, with a Heisman Trophy and a national title at Indiana behind it. The pro sample is what's missing, and the honest grade on the Raiders' choice is still an incomplete.
Next April's draft order is being set in public every Sunday
Draft order is the one part of the draft that data can follow in full, because it comes straight from the standings. WalterFootball's Monday Morning Draft for Week 7, posted by Charlie Campbell on Oct. 26, opened with the race for next April's first pick. The Chargers were 0-6, and the Dolphins were 1-5 after their first win of the season.
A week later the Chargers had dropped to 0-7 after a 24-9 loss, and the Titans sat at 1-7. Anyone can check those records, and the strength-of-schedule figures that break ties come from public results as well.
The other half of the board is harder to see. WalterFootball's Nov. 3 stock report moved cornerback Andrew Marshall up with a line that began "In speaking with sources," next to his 2026 numbers of 23 tackles, an interception and five passes broken up.
Production comes from box scores. Projections like Marshall's probably also lean on people inside team buildings, the circle the league reminds about draft integrity every spring. A reader gets more from a mock draft after sorting each line by its source, a box score or a phone call.
The Raiders' next mock is built around a rookie who has barely played
WalterFootball's Week 8 column, posted Nov. 2, already looked past this season for Las Vegas. It gave the Raiders Oklahoma defensive tackle David Stone, who had 33 tackles and two sacks this fall, as a day-two option, and said their first-round pick should go to blocking or receiver help for Mendoza.
That entry treats last April's pick as settled before he has started a game. It may well be right, and Kubiak's own words point the same way. Still, one college lineman's numbers and one NFL team's needs now sit in the same line of a mock, and only the first half rests on a real sample.
The site that owns GamingToday on Facebook says in its about text that it features live betting odds for professional and college sports, the two levels of football a draft board draws on all fall.
If you graded the Raiders' pick in April, keep the grade and write beside it what it rested on, a combine score or something you heard during draft week. Pull it out again once Mendoza has started a full season. A few hundred dropbacks will give you something real to argue with.

Walt
Charlie Campbell