May 6, 2024
With the 2025 NFL Draft behind us, we can check the results of how the prominent mock drafts fared.
Charlie Campbell had the most accurate 2024 NFL Mock Draft with 13 correct picks. This is hardly a surprise, given his amazing track record. The 2025 accuracy was off from everyone because of a surprise trade that occurred involving the No. 2 overall pick, but Charlie and I tied for third. Congratulations to Jacob Camenker and Todd McShay for having the most accurate mock drafts.
Here is how all of the prominent 2025 NFL Mock Drafts scored (if I’m missing someone’s mock, please e-mail me.) Keep in mind that we are scoring prospects to correct teams:
Jacob Camenker – 10
Todd McShay – 10
Charlie Campbell – 9
Walter Cherepinsky – 9
Danny Kelly – 9
Matt Miller – 9
Josh Norris – 9
Pete Prisco – 9
Jonathan Jones – 8
Trevor Sikemma – 8
Ben Wasley – 8
Albert Breer – 7
Daniel Jeremiah – 7
Peter Schrager – 7
Matt Youmans – 7
Dane Brugler – 6
Eric Edholm – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Chad Reuter – 6
R.J. White – 6
Bucky Brooks – 5
Mike Florio – 5
Jason La Canfora – 5
Ryan Wilson – 5
Lance Zierlein – 5
Cris Collinsworth – 4
Charles Davis – 4
Shane Hallam – 4
Jimmy Kempski – 4
Thor Nystrom – 4
Evan Silva – 4
Mel Kiper – 3
Rob Rang – 3
Chris Trapasso – 3
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2024:
Charlie Campbell – 13
Peter Schrager – 11
Ben Wasley – 11
Jacob Camenker – 10
Albert Breer – 9
Bucky Brooks – 9
Jason La Canfora – 9
Charles Davis – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Matt Miller – 8
Trevor Sikemma – 8
Lance Zierlein – 8
Dane Brugler – 7
Walter Cherepinsky – 7
Eric Edholm – 7
Tony Pauline – 7
Ryan Wilson – 7
Matt Youmans – 7
Shane Hallam – 6
Jimmy Kempski – 6
Thor Nystrom – 6
Pete Prisco – 6
Chad Reuter – 6
Evan Silva – 6
R.J. White – 6
Cris Collinsworth – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Chris Trapasso – 5
Will Brinson – 4
Mike Florio – 4
Rob Rang – 3
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2023:
Walter Cherepinsky – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Jacob Camenker – 7
Charlie Campbell – 7
Lance Zierlein – 7
Shane Hallam – 6
Todd McShay – 6
Trevor Sikemma – 6
Dane Brugler – 5
Cris Collinsworth – 5
Charles Davis – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Pete Prisco – 5
R.J. White – 5
Ryan Wilson – 5
Kyle Crabbs – 4
Jason La Canfora – 4
Jimmy Kempski – 4
Tony Pauline – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Albert Breer – 3
Will Brinson – 3
Mike Florio – 3
Joe Marino – 3
Matt Miller – 3
Thor Nystrom – 3
Peter Schrager – 3
Evan Silva – 3
Chris Trapasso – 3
Matt Youmans – 3
Eric Edholm – 2
Peter King – 2
Mel Kiper – 2
Chad Reuter – 2
Bucky Brooks – 1
Jon Ledyard – Unable to find his mock draft
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2022:
Charlie Campbell – 11
Eric Edholm – 10
Dane Brugler – 9
Matt Youmans – 9
Albert Breer – 8
Walter Cherepinsky – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Thor Nystrom – 8
R.J. White – 8
Jacob Camenker – 7
Jimmy Kempski – 7
Mel Kiper – 7
Kyle Crabbe – 6
Charles Davis – 6
Shane Hallam – 6
Peter King – 6
Jason La Canfora – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Peter Schrager – 6
Chris Trapasso – 6
Ryan Wilson – 6
Lance Zierlein – 6
Jon Ledyard – 5
Todd McShay – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Evan Silva – 5
Will Brinson – 4
Bucky Brooks – 4
Cris Collinsworth – 4
Mike Florio – 4
Pete Prisco – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Trevor Sikemma – 4
Joe Marino – 3
Chad Reuter – 3
Matt Miller – 1
Scott Wright – Retired from mock drafting
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2021:
Josh Norris – 15
Charlie Campbell – 13 (not including Etienne to JAX at 33)
Dane Brugler – 13
Trevor Sikemma – 12
Ryan Wilson – 12
Jacob Camenker – 11
Walter Cherepinsky – 11
Charles Davis – 11
Evan Silva – 11
Todd McShay – 10
Chris Trapasso – 10
R.J. White – 10
Albert Breer – 9
Kyle Crabbe – 9
Lance Zierlein – 9
Peter King – 8
Jon Ledyard – 8
Will Brinson – 7
Mel Kiper – 7
Jason La Canfora – 7
Joe Marino – 7
Pete Prisco – 7
Daniel Jeremiah – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Bucky Brooks – 5
Charley Casserly – 5
Thor Nystrom – 5
Rob Rang – 5
Chad Reuter – 5
Pete Schrager – 5
Cris Collinsworth – 4
Mike Florio – 4
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2020:
Jacob Camenker – 11
Peter King – 10
Scott Wright – 10
Charley Casserly – 9
Pete Schrager – 9
Walter Cherepinsky – 8
Kyle Crabbe – 8
Charles Davis – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Matt Miller – 8
Thor Nystrom – 8
Charlie Campbell – 7
Mike Florio – 7
Jon Ledyard – 7
Joe Marino – 7
Todd McShay – 7
Josh Norris – 7
Tony Pauline – 7
Chad Reuter – 7
Trevor Sikemma – 7
Chris Trapasso – 7
Will Brinson – 6
Dane Brugler – 6
Cris Collinsworth – 6
Mel Kiper – 6
Lance Zierlein – 6
Rob Rang – 5
R.J. White – 5
Bucky Brooks – 4
Evan Silva – 4
Ryan Wilson – 4
Pete Prisco – 3
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2019:
Charlie Campbell – 12
Walter Cherepinsky – 9
Todd McShay – 9
Pete Schrager – 9
Trevor Sikemma -9
Dane Brugler – 8
Jacob Camenker – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Evan Silva – 8
Bucky Brooks – 7
Kyle Crabbe – 7
Peter King – 7
Mel Kiper – 7
Matt Miller – 7
Josh Norris – 7
Lance Zierlein – 7
Charles Davis – 6
Mike Florio – 6
Ryan Wilson – 6
Scott Wright – 6
Will Brinson – 5
Charley Casserly – 5
Joe Marino – 5
Bob McGinn – 5
Chris Trapasso – 5
R.J. White – 5
Thor Nystrom – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Jon Ledyard – 3
Tony Pauline – 3
Chad Reuter – 3
Pete Prisco – 2
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2018:
Walter Cherepinsky – 10
Evan Silva – 10
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Rob Rang – 8
Mike Mayock – 7
Todd McShay – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Bob McGinn – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Pete Prisco – 5
Pete Schrager – 5
Lance Zierlein – 5
Charlie Campbell – 4
Mel Kiper – 4
Will Brinson – 3
Jacob Camenker – 3
Charley Casserly – 3
Scott Wright – 3
Bucky Brooks – 2
Dane Brugler – 2
Peter King – 2
Matt Miller – 2
Thor Nystrom – 2
Chris Trapasso – 2
R.J. White – 2
Chad Reuter – 1
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2017:
Charlie Campbell – 9
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Peter King – 7
Lance Zierlein – 6
Matt Miller – 6
Walter Cherepinsky – 5
Mike Mayock – 5
Evan Silva – 5
Scott Wright – 5
Bucky Brooks – 4
Todd McShay – 4
Josh Norris – 4
Tony Pauline – 4
Pete Prisco – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Pete Schrager – 4
Dane Brugler – 3
Chad Reuter – 3
Charley Casserly – 2
Mel Kiper – 2
Bob McGinn – 2
Let’s combine the past nine years and see who has the most correct over that span:
Charlie Campbell – 85
Walter Cherepinsky – 75
Daniel Jeremiah – 69
Jacob Camenker – 67
Josh Norris – 62
Dane Brugler – 59
Peter Schrager – 59
Lance Zierlein – 59
Evan Silva – 56
Trevor Sikemma – 54
Tony Pauline – 49
Charles Davis – 48
Todd McShay – 47
R.J. White – 47
Pete Prisco – 45
Ryan Wilson – 45
Matt Miller – 44
Peter King – 42
Bucky Brooks – 41
Thor Nystrom – 40
Rob Rang – 40
Chris Trapasso – 39
Mel Kiper – 38
Albert Breer – 36
Chad Reuter – 36
Kyle Crabbs – 34
Will Brinson – 32
Mike Florio – 32
Jason La Canfora – 31
Cris Collinsworth – 28
Matt Youmans – 26
Eric Edholm – 25
Joe Marino – 25
Jon Ledyard – 23
Shane Hallam – 22
Jimmy Kempski – 21
Ben Wasley – 19
Danny Kelly – 9
Jonathan Jones – 8
For a full list of mocks, check out our NFL Mock Draft Database.
Fantasy Football Rankings - May 10
2026 NFL Mock Draft - May 6
NFL Power Rankings - March 28
NFL Picks - Feb. 9
