Charone Peake would be a huge reach hear for the 49ers. Mark my words Garnett is going to be day 1 starter for the 49ers and a good one. You and everyone are going to look like idiots when it comes to your grade with this pick.
@pcich You are right about totally right about the Zeke Elliott I would grade their pick as a B, he is going to be a stud. As most 49ers fans feel Garnett, he is stud and going to be a ten year starter. Seattle at met with him during the pre draft process and had to be looking at him especially when they traded down to 31. He was rated in quite few mocks in 35-50 range. I don't its a stretch at all. As usual Walt has no clue to what he is talking about. I mean he gave Keanu Neal a C- grade and he was a huge reach for the Falcons. Also Walt's extreme bias against the 49ers comes into play. I think Jed York and Walt went to school together and Jed beat up Walt and stole his lunch money.
NFL Draft Mailbag Notes: These are not actually e-mails. They are comments left on the comment board in my 2011 NFL Mock Draft. I've included some of these comments and my responses to them.
2011 NFL Draft E-mails - Hate Mail
From Corey Miller:
Don't you guys find it a little funny that as soon as Mel Kiper mocks Cam Newton to the Bills, Walt scrambles to make a new mock that has the Bills drafting Newton? There's no viable source or any evidence that justifies Walt changing his pick suddenly to Newton other than Kiper's mock.
--> I actually released my mock about 12 hours before Mel Kiper, so if you want to be technical, Kiper copied me :-). Maybe you should send him some hate mail instead.
The pick makes sense. The Bills need a quarterback. Newton's stock is on the rise after his private workout. Reports indicate that the Bills like Newton. It seems like it's bound to happen.
Nobody knows what character concerns he is referring to about Ryan Mallett. This guy thinks he has inside information that he cannot reveal, thus making him feel special when people ask about his character concerns.
--> I don't need to do that to make myself feel special. My mommy says I'm special, so I know I'm special.
Oh, and here's an e-mail from Tom P. who actually agrees with me about Mallett:
I am a current UArk student and as such love the Hogs, so that will get rid of the haters. If you want Mallett character issues, see if you can find information on Scantron gate, his reaction to it (it would make a 2-year-old blush), his locker room conduct at UMich and his tardy policy to classes. Also, the Hog offense did not miss a beat with Wilson under center, as he almost beat two top ranked teams while Mallett was out with a concussion.
Mallett is this year's Ryan Leaf, Jamarcus Russell: a huge physical talent without the brains or drive to put it together. He feels entitled (more so than Clausen, we remember his reaction to the number issue UnderArmour Bowl back in 2007) and does not do the work needed to be elite. Mallett is not popular on a campus that loves its football. That should be the biggest sign.
your retarted.....the vikings will get a quaterback first round...
--> Even if Cam Newton and Blaine Gabbert are off the board? That's smart. I can just hear the Vikings brass thinking, "Let's take a crappy quarterback we could just draft in Round 2 with the No. 12 pick! That'll make us awesome!"
OK WTF Ben Chppel should go in the 2nd round he is the 5th best QB in the draft (also ahead of cam newton) and Doss was the best WR in the big ten how is he not at 3rd round pick at least
--> My advice is to drop the crack pipe and check into a drug rehab facility.
Leonard Hankerson to the Colts is not going to happen guarenteed. Extremely stupid
--> So, let me get this straight. The Colts need a receiver. Leonard Hankerson, if he's still on the board, would be the best player available in the middle of Round 2. Yep, no chance that happens. Extremely stupid indeed.
From Mel Kiper:
I DRAFT GENIUS MAKE PIKE RITE NIQQA. I BEST IN BUSENESS AT MOCK DRAFT. HER MY PANTER PIKE ROUND 1. NICK FAIRLEY ROUND 2. AFTER TRADING STEVE SMTIH WE GRAB AJ GREEN ROUND 3. MARCEL DAREUS TO STRENGTHEN D LINE ROUND 4. CAM NEWTON HE SUCK ROUND 5. ROBERT QUINN DAMN NIQQA THATS A GOOD MOCK
--> Wow, my site is so awesome. I even have Mel Kiper commenting on my mock draft!