Mostly agree with your rankings; with the optimism bias from being a cardinals fan personally, I'd argue you could make a 1 star increase at each position, but their current rankings are also fair. I very much disagree with the 1 star ranking at special teams however, as we have a pro bowl gunner in Justin Bethel being joined by some high upside athletes in the kick coverage team and kick return game. Probably the best coverage unit in the game, which coupled with a punter who is below average (don't think he's as bad as stats show- his hangtime is rediculous, and it seems the staff went with him for this reason. I'd choose a distance leg with our coverage team, butI digress). In short, I'd say 3 stars is fair. A perfectly average special teams unit, whose only limitation really seems to be Drew Butler's distance and the uncertainty of a new long snapper (but both seem pretty reliable this far)
2012 NFL Free Agency: Star rating is out of five. Age listing as of Sept. 1, 2012.
Follow me @walterfootball for updates.
Mike Wallace (RFA), WR, Steelers. Age: 26. Tendered by Steelers (1st)
Mike Wallace is one of the top deep threats in football. The Steelers won't let him get away.
Dwayne Bowe, WR, Chiefs. Age: 27. Franchised by Chiefs
Dwayne Bowe is a dynamic talent and one of the better receivers in the NFL. His production is remarkable considering the mediocre quarterbacks he's worked with throughout his professional career.
Vincent Jackson, WR, Chargers, Chargers. Age: 29. Signed with Buccaneers (5 years, $55 million; $36 million guaranteed)
Vincent Jackson amazingly has never caught more than 68 passes in a single season, but with his size (6-5, 230) and downfield ability, he's one of the top physical talents at the wide receiver position in the NFL.
Wes Welker, WR, Patriots. Age: 31. Franchised by Patriots
The top slot receiver in the NFL, Wes Welker is due for a big contract. He still has a few great years left.
Steve Johnson, WR, Bills. Age: 26. Re-signed with Bills (5 years, $36.25 million; $19.5 million guaranteed)
If Steve Johnson were as strong mentally as he is physically, he would be one of the top receivers in the NFL. Unfortunately, he has way too many drops in key moments and acts like a clown on the field.
Brandon Lloyd, WR, Rams. Age: 31. Signed with Patriots
A legitimate No. 1 receiver, Brandon Lloyd has announced that he'll follow Josh McDaniels wherever he goes. That's a smart football decision, as Lloyd has thrived under McDaniels the past two seasons.
Marques Colston's numbers are awesome, but there are two issues here. First, is he just a product of New Orleans' system? And second, if he's willing to take more money to play for a bad team, that'll speak volumes about his priorities. Just ask the Seahawks how they feel about Sidney Rice.
DeSean Jackson, WR, Eagles. Age: 25. Re-signed with Eagles (5 years, $51 million)
DeSean Jackson was pretty overrated until he started dropping passes and running half-hearted routes in the middle of the season. The threat of Jackson burning teams deep still has an impact on the game, but if lazy coaches would realize that the quick wideout has been pretty mediocre since suffering a second concussion against the Texans last year, they wouldn't respect him as much.
Reggie Wayne, WR, Colts. Age: 33. Re-signed with Colts (3 years, $17.5 million)
Reggie Wayne turns 34 in November. He might still be able to get it done as a No. 2 receiver somewhere next year - perhaps wherever Peyton Manning lands. I'm sure both the Redskins and Jets would be happy with the pair.
Mario Manningham, WR, Giants. Age: 26. Signed with 49ers (2 years)
Mario Manningham is a talented, young receiver who caught 60 balls for 944 yards in 2010. His stats were down this past season because of a nagging knee injury.
Pierre Garcon, WR, Colts. Age: 26. Signed with Redskins
Pierre Garcon is fast, but is also unreliable because he drops too many passes. Still, he had some big games with Curtis Painter and Dan Orlovsky at quarterback, so teams know he's not just a product of the system.
Laurent Robinson, WR, Cowboys. Age: 27. Signed with Jaguars (5 years, $32.5 million)
Laurent Robinson was finally able to stay healthy, and he consequently had the best year of his career, catching 54 balls for 858 yards and 11 touchdowns. He was a key contributor when Miles Austin-Jones went down, so Jerry Jones will make a strong effort to re-sign him. Robinson is injury-prone though, so Jerry better not go crazy.
Robert Meachem, WR, Saints. Age: 27. Signed with Chargers (4 years, $25.9 million)
It's frustrating, but Robert Meachem has never lived up to his potential. He has talent, but it appears as though he's destined to be a mediocre wideout for his entire career.
Braylon Edwards, WR, 49ers. Age: 29. Signed with Seahawks
Braylon Edwards sucked this past year because he was battling injuries. He can be a starter again if he can get healthy.
Danny Amendola (RFA), WR, Rams. Age: 26. Tendered by Rams (2nd)
Sam Bradford's favorite receiver, Danny Amendola missed most of 2011 because of torn triceps. He'll bounce back as a solid slot receiver next year.
Ted Ginn, WR/KR, 49ers. Age: 27. Re-signed with 49ers (1 year)
Ted Ginn stinks as a receiver, but he's one of the top return specialists in the NFL.
Eric Weems, WR/KR, Falcons. Age: 27. Signed with Bears (3 years)
Eric Weems scored two special-teams touchdowns in 2010, but couldn't find the end zone this past season. However, he was still effective on returns, maintaining solid averages in both punt and kick returns.
Deion Branch is worth much more to the Patriots than he is to anyone else. He knows the system, and Tom Brady loves throwing to him.
Josh Morgan, WR, 49ers. Age: 27. Signed with Redskins (5 years, $12 million; $7.5 million guaranteed)
Josh Morgan looked like he was on his way to having a solid year, catching 15 balls for 220 yards in five games, but he went on injured reserve with a broken leg.
Jerome Simpson, WR, Bengals. Age: 26. Signed with Vikings (1 year)
Jerome Simpson had that acrobatic touchdown in Week 16, but was otherwise really inconsistent. He's still young though, and the talent is unquestionably there. Unfortunately, his alleged drug connections downgrade him.
Eddie Royal, WR/PR, Broncos. Age: 26. Signed with Chargers (3 years)
Eddie Royal has inexplicably completely regressed as a receiver, but he's a pretty dynamic punt-returner.
Jacoby Jones, WR/KR, Texans. Age: 28. Signed with Ravens (2 years, $7 million)
Jacoby Jones has never lived up to expectations as a receiver, but he's an effective return specialist. He took a punt back for a touchdown in 2011.
Plaxico Burress, WR, Jets. Age: 35.
All Plaxico Burress does is catch touchdown passes. That's all he can do at this point of his career, anyway.
Harry Douglas, WR, Falcons. Age: 27. -- Re-signed with Falcons
Lee Evans, WR, Ravens. Age: 31. -- Re-signed with Jaguars (1 year)
Jabar Gaffney, WR, Redskins. Age: 31. -- Signed with Patriots (2 years)
Legedu Naanee, WR, Panthers. Age: 28. -- Signed with Dolphins (1 year)
Donte' Stallworth, WR, Redskins. Age: 31. -- Signed with Patriots
Matt Slater, WR/S, Patriots. Age: 26. -- Re-signed with Patriots
Kevin Ogletree, WR, Cowboys. Age: 25. -- Re-signed with Cowboys (1 year)
Donnie Avery, WR, Titans. Age: 28. -- Signed with Colts
Adrian Arrington, WR, Saints. Age: 26.
Andre Caldwell, WR, Bengals. Age: 27. -- Signed with Broncos
Devin Aromashodu, WR, Vikings. Age: 28. -- Re-signed with Vikings
Mark Clayton, WR, Rams. Age: 30.
Derek Hagan, WR, Bills. Age: 27. -- Re-signed with Bills
Michael Spurlock, KR, Buccaneers. Age: 29. -- Signed with Chargers
Patrick Crayton, WR, Chargers. Age: 33.
Chaz Schilens, WR, Raiders. Age: 26. -- Signed with Jets
Roy Williams, WR, Bears. Age: 30.
Anthony Gonzalez, WR, Patriots. Age: 27.
Steve Smith, WR, Eagles. Age: 27. -- Signed with Rams
Mike Williams, WR, Seahawks. Age: 28.
Chad Johnson, WR, Dolphins. Age: 34.
Hines Ward, WR, Steelers. Age: 36. -- Announced retirement
Brandon Stokley, WR, None. Age: 36. -- Signed with Broncos
Matt Willis (RFA), WR, Broncos. Age: 28. -- Re-signed with Broncos (1 year, $1.26 million)
Patrick Turner, WR, Jets. Age: 25. -- Re-signed with Jets
Bryant Johnson, WR, Texans. Age: 31. -- Re-signed with Texans
Roscoe Parrish, WR, Bills. Age: 30. -- Signed with Chargers
Devin Thomas, WR, Bears. Age: 25. -- Announced retirement
Greg Camarillo, WR, Vikings. Age: 30.
Domenik Hixon, WR/KR, Giants. Age: 27. -- Re-signed with Giants
Jerheme Urban, WR, Chiefs. Age: 31.
Ruvell Martin, WR, Bills. Age: 30. -- Re-signed with Bills
Michael Clayton, WR, Giants. Age: 29.
Maurice Stovall, WR, Lions. Age: 27. -- Re-signed with Lions
Courtney Roby, WR/KR, Saints. Age: 29. -- Re-signed with Saints
Chansi Stuckey, WR, Cardinals. Age: 28.
Kassim Osgood, WR, Jaguars. Age: 32.
Rashied Davis, WR, Lions. Age: 33. -- Signed with Bears
Brett Swain, WR, 49ers. Age: 27. -- Re-signed with 49ers
Arnaz Battle, WR, Steelers. Age: 32.
T.J. Houshmandzadeh, WR, Raiders. Age: 34.
Terrell Owens, WR, Bengals. Age: 38. -- Signed with Seahawks
Randy Moss, WR, Titans. Age: 35. Signed with 49ers (1 year)
Here's the list of teams interested in Randy Moss:
Matt Millen's Kielbasa Killers Fantasy Team
Moss is done. He couldn't separate from corners in 2010. He couldn't even get on the field for the Titans. He's a horrible guy to have in the locker room because he's a quitter. No general manager in his right mind will want to sign this bum.