Funny. Clearly your not a Cowboy fan so it clouds your thoughts. Pretty hard to determine a players potential before they take a snap in the NFL. With that its pretty strong to say they blew the pick. If in the next few years Elliott is a top 5 RB and returns the offense to 2014 form its hardly blowing it. Ramsey looks to be a great player too. But Dallas needed to put a top RB behind that OL before contracts split it up as much as a top DB. The RB helps crown the OL, reduces the QB hits and frees up the passing game. Ramsey may not have as big an impact in Jacksonville as Elliott will have in Dallas. We will see.........
This is Matt McGuire's NFL Draft blog, where he'll talk about the NFL Draft, anything that has to do with football and whatever else is on his mind. Send Matt an e-mail here: [email protected].
All other e-mail, including advertising and link proposals, send to: [email protected]
Posted March 20, 2009
With the 2009 NFL Draft just around the corner, it becomes painfully obvious to me who watches tape and who doesn�t. You can always tell who the television analysts are who do not watch tape because they only discuss four things: height, weight, speed and stats. These are numbers, it is lazy research, and they can string a few sentences out and not say anything. I spent hundreds of hours this fall and winter watching the tapes I recorded of NCAA football games this season, and I have compiled my All-Overhyped and All-Underrated teams for the 2009 NFL Draft.
QB: Nate Davis, Ball State
RB: Shonn Greene, Iowa
WR: Jeremy Maclin, Missouri
TE: Shawn Nelson, Southern Mississippi
T: Andre Smith, Alabama
G: Herman Johnson, Louisiana State
C: Max Unger, Oregon
DE: Michael Johnson, Georgia Tech
DT: Fili Moala, Southern Cal
DE/OLB: Aaron Maybin, Penn State
OLB: Brian Cushing, Southern Cal
ILB: Darry Beckwith, Louisiana State
CB: Sean Smith, Utah
QB: Matthew Stafford, Georgia
RB: Kory Sheets, Purdue
WR: Brandon Gibson, Washington State
TE: Travis Beckum, Wisconsin
T: Gerald Cadogan, Penn State
G: Robert Brewster, Ball State
C: Jonathan Luigs, Arkansas
DE: Kyle Moore, Southern Cal
DT: Alex Magee, Purdue
DE/OLB: Phillip Hunt, Houston
OLB: Nic Harris, Oklahoma
ILB: Gerald McRath, Southern Mississippi
CB: Mark Parson, Ohio
S: Rashad Johnson, Alabama
Yes, Stafford is underrated. He should be on the top three of everyone�s big boards. Unfortunately, most NFL Draft analysts do not understand that being an underclassman and rated high does not cause a quarterback to bust. They do not do the research to see that quarterbacks with elite arms coming from pro-style offenses in college with elite intangibles and solid offensive line protection have never busted in the NFL. I am not saying Stafford can�t bust; I just think it has a low probability to actually happen because of his makeup. To think he is not worthy of a No. 1 pick, in my mind, is quite ridiculous.