When drafting you want to have your draft cheatsheet gathered into tiers to help you find value and not overreach for someone. But tiers are also subjective enough that you need to feel confident in your tiering so you don't second guess yourself. It's still early in the offseason, so these tiers will change, but we're already mocking and drafting in best-ball leagues, so there is no time like the present to start grouping players.
This tier is about as locked in as you'll get, and you'll no doubt see these three across the fantasy football landscape in some order, but always these three together. I could see going with just Bell and Johnson as Tier 1, as Elliott won't see as many targets as they will, but he could see more work through the air this year and his offensive line is easily the best in the league, which makes him one of the safer plays in the league.
This group isn't as safe as the first tier, but all signs point to high usage in 2017, both on the ground and through the air. Gordon has a better offensive line now and no real competition at running back, and McCoy should see more targets and continue to be the base of the Bills' offense this year. Howard and Ajayi are the keys to their offenses, and Freeman, despite losing some touches to Tevin Coleman, has proven his worth in a high-powered offense and should continue to be a touchdown maker despite not being a bruising goal-line back.
This is the first group where I have reservations, but I also feel that healthy seasons should result in strong fantasy finishes, which I can't really say definitively about the guys below this tier. If Murray and Lynch were a bit younger, they'd likely be moved up, but as it is, I feel like these guys all have good upside, but more reasons to worry than those in Tier 2.
This tier has a lot of upside, but also some real blatant risk. All of these backs will be competing for touches, but they also are my picks to lead their respective backfields this season. If you think Joe Williams, Thomas Rawls, Jamaal Charles, Matt Forte, Kareem Hunt, etc., are the players to own in their camp battles, then you'll need to be sure to craft your own tier rankings, because these aren't the tier rankings you are looking for.
Will Ingram or Peterson lead the way in New Orleans? Despite Paul Perkins' No. 1 ranking on the depth chart, will the Giants ever be able to get their running game going? Is Gillislee set up to take those 18 rushing touchdowns from LeGarrette Blount this season? Can Abdullah finally stay healthy and lead the way in Detroit? Can Blount take his touchdown show on the road to Philadelphia? The answer to these questions is "Yes." Well, the first one isn't a "yes or no' question is it? That's okay, I'll give them both a "Yes" this season and then draft whoever falls the farthest.
The risk, of course, keeps building, but these are all players I see with a good chance to lead their teams in touches this season and are all in good enough offenses to take advantage.
This looks like a PPR tier for the most part, as a majority of these guys are set up for a goodly amount of targets, except for Henry. Henry is a lead back and could easily be a league winner if DeMarco Murray were to be sidelined, but Henry will need that to happen, because there just isn't enough work to make him a fantasy star. But yes, the rest of these guys are all PPR stars in the making or in Frank Gore's case, an old man who can still do everything well, just not quite as fast and that includes catching the ball.
Of course in PPR leagues, these guys get a boost, but they still have a lot of appeal in standard leagues, so don't let them fall too far.
I believe all these guys have a decent shot at leading their teams in touches this season. Cook has the highest upside of this group, but is a rookie and has a lot of competition, while Martin is probably the safest despite his suspension. I like Perine to beat out Rob Kelley, but Perine will still lose work to Chris Thompson in the passing game and Kelley won't just disappear completely. And even though I like Spencer Ware more than Hunt, I know there is going to be plenty of competition between the two, and Hunt could come out on top. I've been back and forth in my thinking on Jonathan Stewart, as Christian McCaffery is going to take a lot of his work, but a lot will depend on Stewart's looks around the goal line. If Cam Newton continues to steal goal-line work, then Stewart could be blocked from those touches again.
Tier Eight is a group that I like if I can get them at value. Some rookies who have a shot at the very least being their team's backup in Mack, Foreman, Williams and the other Williams, plus a couple of oldies who will still see a decent amount of work while healthy in Forte and Sproles. And Thompson is a PPR player I'm always a fan of for bye weeks.
Tier Nine is a mixed bag of players I like as bench fodder at the right price. They all have a little upside and could easily move up as camp battles and injuries get into full swing.
I believe all of these players are draftable in deeper leagues and have some upside, but at the moment, they aren't poised to see much work.