Debaclation Nation

I'm pretty shocked by how many votes Vince Young has received.

Mcnabb sucks. He's awful. I should be higher on the list than he is.

I voted for Hasselbeck, because he's the only one on the list who's actually good, in reality. Alex Smith=hard fail. Billy Volek is the guy I get confused with Kerry Collins and all the other old ones. Marc Bulger, well I only know he's good from Madden 06. McNabb is probably the second-best option seeing as he's a veteran, but he's not going to win you anything. Vince Young is Vince Young. Kyle Orton is probably the third-best option, seeing as he has had a good season in the last 10 years, but that was only once, plus his face is totally lame. Kevin Kolb I refuse to rate so highly because he's made like under 10 career starts and played like trash in at least one of them. Plus his face is a big no-no too. The only problem with Hasselbeck (which I'll admit is a concern) is he's kind of old/fragile. On his day, he's by far the best of all the QBs listed.

Obviously Some Guy's idea is the best though.

VY is a nut case and can't be trusted.

I voted Orton because he has managed to put up solid statistics in the past and, while he never seems to do it on a good team, he's certainly "Game Manager" qualified, Kolb would cost more money AND picks to acquire, and since Orton proved that he could thrive in a McDaniels college-style spread offense, I would adopt that system since I shouldn't have too much trouble finding college players who could play in that style.

Why not try to trade for Matt Flynn?

After that I'd take Kolb, then Orton, then Young. I think Flynn's a FA next year, so why not try to get some value out of him?

Sounds like a pretty damn good idea considering the choices

I choose to bomb the season and take Andrew Luck.

Kolb is fragile, and teammates don't rally around Orton on the field, so I gotta say VY

Tough choice between Orton and Kolb, but ultimately it came down to who would you rather have - the player whose performance is unknown in high pressure situations, or the player who is known to fail? So I went with Kolb.

If you want a QB that wins and is still young You have to get Vince Young. After that Kyle Orton and Kolb. Why the hell is Billy Volek on there. LOL

First comment... we're going to have comment boards like this all over the site soon. We're still working out the kinks, so this is not the finished product.